By Tanya Craft, Audrey Gagie, and Anna Birch
The email went out and a shock wave rippled through the entire ministry organization.
Their long-tenured leader was unexpectedly leaving.
Her notice came as such a surprise that many in the organization–and on the Board–feared what would happen with the well-established ministry. Holding her position for many years, she had become known as the face of the ministry and driving force of the mission. What would happen now that she had stepped down?
The problem was not just that she resigned without explanation, but that there was no one readily available to sit in her now-empty seat. Could the ministry survive without its faithful leader at the helm?
The leader was aware of the commotion that her leaving would cause and had drafted a communication plan to staff, leadership, and donors in an attempt to ease the immediate blow. She also offered to slowly transition out of the position over a specified period of time.
The plan worked, but only temporarily. In the initial weeks after the news hit, it maintained the calm and reassured the stakeholders. However, hidden cracks in the plan and organization at large began to appear. The remaining staff began feeling uncertain and uneasy about the future of the ministry. The leadership team struggled to reassign responsibilities effectively. Due to the lack of reason given for the exit, key staff members began to leave, which increased the workload of those who remained.
A snowball effect began to take place. Roles and responsibilities were reshuffled to keep operations moving, leading to inefficiencies and confusion. Recruiting, onboarding, and training of replacements strained the budget. Some of the donors began to reduce or withdraw support as their confidence was shaken and their concern grew. Was the organization stable? Was the mission to stay on target?
Sadly, program delivery slowed, community outreach suffered, and momentum was lost in key initiatives. What was initially a natural occurrence in every ministry–a key leader leaving–became a disaster for this ministry.
Succession planning is faithful stewardship of the mission.
An unhealthy view that many of us in ministry have is to think that a certain leader is the ministry instead of remembering that God has placed them there “for such a time as this.” And that “time” will not be forever. The ministry God forms should be able to carry on without one specific person. In fact, a sign of health is when the ministry continues—because a new leader steps in.
Because we cannot always predict when a change in leadership will happen, leaders need to be accountable for being as ready for the potential change as possible.
A scarcity mindset says “we can’t find someone else that can lead like they can.” The problem is that that type of thinking often causes leaders to stay in place too long, as well as those under them to feel stifled and incapable of leading.
By contrast, when a leader knows that it is the Lord who truly is in charge and in control, they can release their grip on their position and see it as stewardship, encouraging another to be ready to take over when the time is right.
When a leader knows that every breath they breathe is a gift and that God has them in place for a season–not forever–they begin to think about how to replace themselves. Something to ask ourselves as leaders is this:
“If God were to call me away from this ministry tomorrow, either to another ministry or to my Heavenly Home, who would take over? Who could take over? Am I readying the next generation for the task of stepping up to the plate?”
Many leaders might respond with insecurity and fear over a succession plan. Does this mean I will be outed at the organization if I give even a hint of wanting to retire or move on? Let us be organizations that are ready for the next step, and content with the current, healthy leadership that is in place. Fear is never a good foundation with which to make a decision.
When we look at Scripture, we see God supplying new leaders in place of ones exiting for various reasons. Elijah and Elisha are the classic examples of a veteran leader empowering a younger leader to take over.
Pastor David Guzek, in his commentary on 1 Kings says:
“Elijah also needed hope, and since Elisha would be raised up as a successor to Elijah’s prophetic office, Elijah then knew that his work would continue even after his death.”
What an effective picture of succession planning and discipleship!
So what happened to the ministry that lost its beloved leader? What initially caused fear and confusion over the future and spelled disaster for the organization, ended up being an opportunity for healthy change and growth within the ministry.
The organization did finally realize where they went off course. They realized that proactive succession planning could have greatly reduced the disruption, preserved donor confidence, and protected the mission.
Here are some questions to ask as an organization:
-
What are your most critical roles?
-
Who in the organization is aligned with the expectations and most capable of stepping into them?
-
What plans do we need in place to ensure we remain healthy?
We can be leaders who pray dependently and plan diligently at the same time. Let us be faithful stewards and begin developing new leaders before the need is urgent.
If succession planning is something your organization struggles to implement, we can help you identify critical roles and design a simple, biblically grounded, succession pathway.
👉 Schedule a 30-minute readiness conversation today.
Stay tuned: In our next article, we will look at how to define what good leadership looks like so you know exactly what qualities to seek and grow in future leaders.


